Birth is about the baby, not the mom. So do it in the hospital.
There is alot of pressure for pregnant moms these days to commit to experiencing a natural childbirth, and even a home birth. These processes have been romanticized lately as a less traumatic experience for the newborn and for the mom. And for the cases of childbirth where everything is normal....well, great. But in the event that anything goes wrong, the trauma from an attempt at a natural birth or home birth increases exponentially. Let's remember that one in three woman used to die in childbirth. So when hospitals treat birth as a "medical emergency", there is a reason they are doing this. Ricki Lake's movie The Business of Being Born promotes home birth and natural childbirth, and paints the hospital to be big, bad and out to get you.
Many women enter their birthing process with a birthing plan. Hospitals have reputations for ignoring them. Why? Because an expectant mom has NO IDEA what is going to happen once she goes into labor. Birthing plans are written in the event that everything goes great, no complications, baby is born on the exact due date or very close to it. How often does this happen? Not too often.
Home birth means the baby is born at home, commonly assisted by a mid-wife. A mid-wife is great for normal deliveries, but as soon as anything goes wrong everyone gets rushed to the hospital, hopefully with enough time to save everyone involved. Hospitals typically allow mid-wives in the delivery room, and many hospitals allow the patient to request a mid-wife instead of a doctor. Seems like a great alternative to home birth. Besides, who has a home cleaner than a hospital?
Natural childbirth means childbirth without drugs - no epidural, no induction medications, no drugs. That sounds great for the scenario where the baby is born close to due date, mom's labor doesn't last for multiple days, noone gets dehydrated, and the baby slides right out with no problems. In hospitals, babies who are more than a week late are typically induced, for fear that 1) the placenta may dry up and no longer be able to nourish the baby, and 2) meconium gets passed into the amniotic fluid and swallowed by baby, causing lung infections, and 3) the baby doesn't get so large that he no longer fits in the birth canal.
My personal experience with my first son is that he was 8 days late, we went in for the induction, I labored for 24 hours with very little dilation, and then had an emergency C-section after his heart failed twice from the induction drugs. Upon doing the C-section, we realized the problem was his head was simply too large to even start a descent down the birth canal. If the year had been 1800 the doctor would have broken my pelvis to deliver the baby - we may or may not have survived. Thank GOD for drugs, and hospital procedure. My second son was born via planned C-section - it was fantastic. If I could have scheduled a C-section the first time round I would have - it clearly is the method that most greatly reduces all risks to the baby associated with childbirth.
It is my opinion that choosing a home birth and/or a natural birth is completely selfish and not done in the best interest of the child. The other day I saw a woman driving her car with a bumper sticker that said "My child was birthed at home". As far as I can tell, that is ALL you get from a successful home birth - a bumper sticker. A chance to show off your own actions in the birthing process....but what does that have to do with the baby? Birthing is not about the mom - birthing is about the baby. Expectant moms need to make the choice that reduces the risk for problems for their child.


